JOHANNESBURG, Gauteng — The African Legal Professionals Association (ALPA) has approached the Constitutional Court in an urgent bid to overturn a Western Cape High Court ruling that permitted the Section 89 impeachment committee to rescind its recommendation of Advocate Griffiths Thandazani Madonsela SC as the chief evidence leader in the inquiry into President Cyril Ramaphosa.
The legal challenge centers on the committee’s decision to withdraw Madonsela’s appointment following allegations of a conflict of interest. President Ramaphosa’s legal submissions argued that Madonsela poses a clear conflict of interest, noting that the President removed him from the Judicial Service Commission in 2022, which allegedly creates a risk of personal grievance. Additionally, it was noted that Madonsela had previously advised the ANC on matters tied to this exact impeachment inquiry.
However, ALPA Chairperson Sthembiso Mbhele strongly contests the rescission, arguing that the decision was contrived and lacked a rational, lawful basis.
Urgent Direct Access Sought
Addressing the procedural hurdles of bypassing the Supreme Court of Appeal, Mbhele stated that ALPA is confident the Constitutional Court will grant direct access due to the gravity and public importance of the matter. He emphasized that adhering to lengthier, conventional legal processes would unnecessarily delay the proceedings, placing the matter firmly in the hands of the highest court to resolve without undue procedural obstruction.
Contesting the “New Information” Claim
A central pillar of ALPA’s argument is that the committee’s justification for changing its mind was based on fabricated grounds. Mbhele clarified that on August 5, 2026, when the committee initially recommended Madonsela as the chief evidence leader, Madonsela had already provided written disclosure that he had previously advised a parliamentary group on legal matters arising from the impeachment process.
“The committee’s legal advisor took the committee through that disclosure made by Advocate Madonsela regarding the role he had played previously,” Mbhele explained. He argued that the committee’s claim of acting on “material new information” is factually incorrect, as this information was already on the record at the time of the initial recommendation. Mbhele also pointed to the fact that the Western Cape High Court judgment was not unanimous, providing ALPA with a strong legal foundation for their appeal.
Upholding the Rule of Law
When questioned about whether the committee was merely exercising its statutory power to avoid future legal challenges, Mbhele drew a firm line between procedural strategy and constitutional compliance. He stressed that because the Section 89 committee, appointed by the National Assembly, exercises public power, all its decisions must strictly comply with the rule of law.
“For us as ALPA, this is not about protecting the inquiry from future legal battles; it is about upholding the rule of law,” Mbhele asserted. He maintained that while a committee has the latitude to change its mind, it must do so on lawful grounds, not on concocted ones that suggest an ulterior motive by Parliament.
Addressing Neutrality Concerns
Addressing public concerns regarding neutrality, Mbhele clarified the nature of Madonsela’s prior legal work. He noted that while Madonsela may have provided legal services to the President on entirely different matters in the past, this does not equate to a conflict of interest regarding the current Phala Phala inquiry.
Mbhele concluded by emphasizing that ALPA’s escalation to the Constitutional Court is not merely about ensuring their client retains the role of chief evidence leader, but fundamentally about ensuring that public power is exercised in strict observance of constitutional standards and the rule of law.



